Betty realizes that the only other person was Clifford Blossom, who hung himself.
Kevin sings as he makes his way down the hall. Alice is just glad that Betty’s safe with the Sisters and wasn't at the school for the incident. He wants to come home.Veronica and Betty asks Hiram for a prison transferBetty and Veronica meet with Hiram at La Bonne Nuit, where Betty asks Hiram for a favor. Betty, Archie, Veronica, Kevin, Cheryl, Toni, Jellybean and FP organize a search party for Jughead in the woods. So he began to feel guilty about catfishing him and decided that he would do it no more. Bret reminds them of Donna’s allegation that she was having an affair with Chipping, but Betty accuses her of lying. The more Jughead plays the game, the more familiar he becomes with Eldervair and its rules.
They invite Betty and Jughead to the Ides of March celebration in the woods behind the school. Admittedly, they’re all monsters, Jughead says. Jughead notes that this is perfect. G&G may not be in the news anymore, but it’s everywhere else. Betty hosts a sleepover with Veronica, Kevin, Cheryl, and ToniBetty hosts a sleepover with Veronica, Cheryl, Toni, and Kevin, who isn’t in the happiest of moods after being kicked off the Variety Show. She starts in the classroom, where she finds the Midnight Club’s initials in the window seal, just as her mother said. Bless me with your darkness, gift me with your flight." Jughead replied that watching Archie's face made him feel better. Jughead also extends Betty another invitation to move back in with him considering things have calmed down since his mom left. Betty points out how this idea is more emotional than practical. Fortunately, as they near the road, the Pretty Poisons and Serpents, led by Cheryl and Toni, begin firing arrows at the Gargoyles.
When Ethel overhears Betty’s conversation with the others, she confronts her, though Betty persist with her claims of having gotten to know the Gargoyle King, which only angers Ethel. Until then, there's still another mystery to be solved. However, Betty argues that Chic is the only person of guilt. Chic attempts to play it off, claiming that Betty's been out to get him from the start and that she never wanted a brother. He demands to know what they were doing. Betty adds that DuPont exploited Jughead’s grandfather. Kevin wonders if they should sign up.
Veronica, Betty, Archie, and Jughead watch Honey get rolled outMr. Unfortunately, Chic began to become angry, instructing them to leave as he had a client on the way. Betty reveals that there’s nothing she’d enjoy more than to give Stonewall Prep a royal ass-kicking, to which Honey, who refers to Betty as caption of the quiz team, gives his full support. They find him sitting on the courtroom steps alone. They joined her by her stand as she gave out kisses and cupcakes. Jughead explained that she and Archie are his friends, everyone else, including Kevin and Veronica are people that he would have actively shunned two months ago because he's weird.
One thing seen in a lot of serial killers are instances of animal cruelty in their youth. How did it go, Alice asks. She peaks through the doors of the chamber to the sight of Evelyn standing before Kevin and Fangs, who are down on their knees singing.
While the theme of Fire and Ice was decided months ago, Betty and Jughead attempt to persuade Cheryl to specify the theme with something more medieval. Hal, Alice, and Betty learning that Polly is leavingDespite Betty's best effort in trying to convince Polly to stay, after reading their mother's published article on the Black Hood, Polly decided it would be safest if she left town until he was apprehended. In spite of all this, Betty refused to blindside her with a published mugshot. Sister Agnes then comes over to give them their daily ration of Fizzle Rocks, which Betty consumes whilst in the Sisters’ presence, but immediately rushes to the bathroom, where she pukes it up.
Betty recalls the affair her father had with Penelope in the middle of the Black Hood attacks last year. Betty goes looking for Jughead, instead, she spots Donna. They become Betty. When inhaled, it leaves the victim disoriented and unaware. She then admitted that Betty was right abut Chic and kicked him out the house. Betty also recalls the Warden calling Archie a Red Paladin. All these things that she doesn't have control over, they terrify her.
As for Claudius, all Penelope knows is that he committed suicide.
Betty then asks Jellybean if she has any fake blood left over from Halloween, which she does. However, Betty and Veronica refuse to allow that to happen. She insisted that he to tell her what happened, but Jughead simply begged her to go home. At first, Archie refuses to leave his father unattended. Surprisingly, Alice decided to attend the event, which both Betty and Polly were thrilled over, however, the Blossoms weren't far behind, which forced Betty to assist in keeping her mother's attitude in check. But since he refuses to recognize that, she’ll just take Jughead’s bike and do this without him. Betty answered, and Cheryl revealed to her the identity of the Sugarman.